Leiden University Student Repository

Piers, Noortje (2024)

Het verlegen kind in een politieverhoor: Een onderzoek naar de rol van kinderpersoonlijkheid in de Nederlandse kinderverhoormethode

Master thesis | Education and Child Studies (MSc)

In the Netherlands, children are interrogated using the Dutch child interrogation method ‘the scenariomodel’. Surprisingly, this method does not consider the impact of children's personality traits, despite literature indicating that these traits play a central role in their perspectives and can therefore influence the course of the interrogation and their testimony. This correlational study investigated the extent to which the personality trait 'shyness' plays a role in the course of the child interrogation according to the scenariomodel and in the quality of the witness statement. The research target group are children under the age of 12 who are victims of online sexual abuse. Participants (N = 23) underwent an ethically responsible simulation of online sexual abuse and a simulation of a child interrogation according to the scenariomodel. The transcripts of the interrogations were coded to first examine the quality of the testimony based on three indicators: accuracy of the...Show moreIn the Netherlands, children are interrogated using the Dutch child interrogation method ‘the scenariomodel’. Surprisingly, this method does not consider the impact of children's personality traits, despite literature indicating that these traits play a central role in their perspectives and can therefore influence the course of the interrogation and their testimony. This correlational study investigated the extent to which the personality trait 'shyness' plays a role in the course of the child interrogation according to the scenariomodel and in the quality of the witness statement. The research target group are children under the age of 12 who are victims of online sexual abuse. Participants (N = 23) underwent an ethically responsible simulation of online sexual abuse and a simulation of a child interrogation according to the scenariomodel. The transcripts of the interrogations were coded to first examine the quality of the testimony based on three indicators: accuracy of the statement, completeness of the statement and the amount of forensic information. And second to investigate the course of the interrogation based on the resistance that children show. Shyness was measured with a questionnaire. The study anticipated that shy children exhibit more resistance and provide lower quality testimonials due to their susceptibility to suggestiveness and social discomfort during interrogations. However, the results showed no significant correlations between shyness and the quality indicators of the testimony, nor between shyness and resistance. A mediating effect of resistance on the quality of the testimony was therefore also excluded. This suggests that the scenariomodel may be resistant to the negative influences of this personality trait and can be used without concern for interrogating shy children who have been victims of online sexual abuse. However, due to important limitations of the study, firm conclusions cannot be drawn and follow-up research is necessary.Show less

kinderverhoor

verlegenheid

scenariomodel

Author

Piers, Noortje

Faculty

Faculty of Social & Behavioural Sciences

Specialisation

Forensische Gezinspedagogiek

Supervisors

Arnout Koornneef

ECTS Credits

20

Language

nl