Studying synchrony between interacting subjects: Comparison of statistical methods to quantify synchrony between subjects

Understanding the functioning of the brain and how it relates to behavior is one of theprimary objectives of neuroscience. The focus of neuroscience has evolved from a singlebrain to studying interactions between multiple brains. In several fields, synchrony inbrain responses between individuals has been proven to positively influence psychologicalprocesses and lead to better outcomes.Time-series data for each subject’s behavior or modality are obtained by measuringsynchrony. Comparative studies for synchrony methods have been carried out in orderto gain some insight into the similarities and differences between many measures forevaluating the synchrony between subjects using such time-series data. The research onlyprovides a partial picture of the performance of the synchrony methods in terms of captur-ing synchrony and the conditions in which these methods are optimal. It is still unknownhow well the synchrony methods perform when changing other data characteristics.The goal of...Show moreUnderstanding the functioning of the brain and how it relates to behavior is one of theprimary objectives of neuroscience. The focus of neuroscience has evolved from a singlebrain to studying interactions between multiple brains. In several fields, synchrony inbrain responses between individuals has been proven to positively influence psychologicalprocesses and lead to better outcomes.Time-series data for each subject’s behavior or modality are obtained by measuringsynchrony. Comparative studies for synchrony methods have been carried out in orderto gain some insight into the similarities and differences between many measures forevaluating the synchrony between subjects using such time-series data. The research onlyprovides a partial picture of the performance of the synchrony methods in terms of captur-ing synchrony and the conditions in which these methods are optimal. It is still unknownhow well the synchrony methods perform when changing other data characteristics.The goal of this study is to evaluate the performance of several methods for capturingdifferent types of synchrony between a pair of time series. Two mechanisms are usedto generate a pair of time-series data with a known amount of synchrony between thetime series (1) two unidirectionally connected Hénon maps, and (2) bivariate von Misesdistribution. Correlations between the two time series are computed as another definitionof true synchrony to provide a different perspective on true synchrony. In addition, asystematical evaluation of the performance of the synchrony methods on simulated datawith various data characteristics is carried out.For the generated data coherence and phase synchrony are the two best performingmethods. Regarding the varied data characteristics, especially the amount of true syn-chrony has a large effect on recovery performance. These main effects between the datacharacteristics are qualified by several two-way and three-way interactions that almostalways include the synchrony methods and the amount of true synchrony. Under all ofthe different data characteristics, no synchrony method is perfect, and all of the synchronymethods in this study are not always stable. As a result, using a combination of differentsynchrony methods to detect synchrony is recommended.Show less

Leiden University Student Repository

Documents

In Collections

Studying synchrony between interacting subjects: Comparison of statistical methods to quantify synchrony between subjects